![]() |
One may ask why one should find links to competitor's products on the Adaptronic site. The answer is simple: at Adaptronic, we want you to compare our products to those of our competitors. Why? We want you to choose the Adaptronic over our competitors because it's the best one for your individual system. If it's not the best one for your technical and cost requirements (eg, if you require on-board datalogging, or if you're on a really really tight budget, or if you don't want adaptive behaviour), you would be better off with another unit.
Incidentally, if you found this page useful and chose not to buy an Adaptronic, we would appreciate a brief email explaining why (even a single line such as "needed more analogue inputs for datalogging" would be helpful).
See the Disclaimer at the bottom.
Entry Level ECUsThese ECUs run open loop fuel control, meaning that they use no feedback for fuel control. This makes them unsuitable for road use (with the exception of the UniChip, as it retains the original factory closed-loop ECU), but are fine for track cars, off-road recreational vehicles, boats etc. |
|
UniChipThe UniChip is a bit of a misnomer, because it isn't a power chip at all, it's actually a piggyback ECU. These connect in parallel with the original ECU and modify the fueling and ignition timing as instructed. This of course relies on the original ECU being available and mostly working (eg, if you change cam profile). Because the factory ECU relies on the factory sensors, if the factory ECU used an air flow meter, this must be retained. |
|
![]() |
EMSEMS have just released a new range of two budget ECUs; the 8860 and the Stinger. |
MicrotechA few models and accessories available. Unlike most other manufacturers, they have price listings. They also have downloadable wiring diagrams for different applications. Microtech will be releasing a new range of ECUs in January. |
|
Closed Loop ECUsThese ECUs run closed loop fuel control, meaning that feedback from the EGO (exhaust gas oxygen) sensor is used to regulate the fuel amount. This correction to the fuel amount is not persistent - ie the fuel map is not corrected itself; instead a correction is applied to the fuel map. |
|
![]() |
HaltechAnother ECU manufacturer, with six ECUs on their website. Many of these run closed loop fuel control, however some Haltech's don't appear to. |
![]() |
WolfNow up to version 4.4, the Wolf 3D also is available in a "plug-in" type, which are suited to specific engines, and save on installation time as there is no wiring to be done. The Wolf 3D ECU runs closed loop fuel control. |
![]() |
HawkAnother generic closed-loop ECU. |
Closed Loop with Adaptive Fuel ControlThese ECUs below have some form of adaptive fuel control. The difference between these and simple closed-loop control is that the fuel correction is integrated back into the fuel map, allowing automatic tuning of the engine, provided the operator holds the engine conditions steady. |
|
![]() |
LinkLink offer stand-alone ECUs as well as boards that replace the factory board inside the original enclosure. The factory replacement ECUs are limited to specific vehicles. With a separate tuning module, some Link ECUs can offer adaptive tuning similar to the Motec. |
![]() |
AutronicA higher level ECU, available as stand-alone or as a replacement board for Mitsubishi or Subaru vehicles. They have an "Autotune" (TM) feature, which is the adaptive fuel tuning mode, however this is extra in cost. This is a true "hands-off" tuning mode, as with the Adaptronic. The Autronic uses slightly different tuning parameters to other ECUs - most store the desired fuel injector duration in milliseconds, whereas the Autronic stores a VE table. This means that you can select a different injector type or target air-fuel ratio without needing to retune the engine. |
![]() |
MotecThese are probably the best known programmable ECU. Very flexible and fairly generously featured, including 512kB of datalogging and versatile crank angle sensor options. Those in the know say they are the best around, but expensive. They have a "Quick Lamba" feature, which is similar to the adaptive fuel control of the Adaptronic, however not intended for continuous use and must be activated via a laptop, as far as can be interpreted from the user manual. |
These specifications were collected from websites of the manufacturers. There is a lot more information that could be put in the table, but many ECUs have these all in common so there would be little benefit. Extra features such as traction control, boost control, barometric pressure compensation and so on have not been included. A blank in the table means that the information was not available. Unfortunately, there are many blanks due to unspecific specification sheets from manufacturers. A question mark indicates an ambiguous specification, or one that does not neatly fit into this table.
Copyright 2002-2006 Andrew Wyatt. All rights reserved. Unauthorised copying of any material anywhere on this site explicitly forbidden unless prior arrangements have been made. Adaptronic is a registered trademark of Andrew Wyatt. Webmaster Jason Broadhurst.